Blender Reviews: Blendtec vs. Vitamix (& Others)

Katie Wells Avatar

Reading Time: 5 minutes

This post contains affiliate links.

Read my affiliate policy.

Blender Reviews: Blendtec vs. vitamix
Wellness Mama » Blog » Reviews » Blender Reviews: Blendtec vs. Vitamix (& Others)

Over the years, we’ve used a lot of different blenders and I’ve written several blender reviews. Cooking from scratch three times a day for eight people gives me a LOT of time to test out blenders while making sauces, smoothies and more. My favorite blender has changed a few times over the years so I figured an updated review was in order!

What to Look For in a Quality Blender

A good blender can last years, so it is worth doing some research before purchasing one!

Before deciding which blender will work for you, consider how often you’ll be using it, how big it needs to be and your budget. I also looked at the warranty length of each blender and how well it could fit in a cabinet or under a counter.

Based on these criteria, I’m sharing my favorite blenders that we’ve used over the years and why. These are our favorites in each category: high-powered, budget-friendly, easiest for kids, and immersion.

Best High Speed Blender

High speed blenders are all the rage. With the continued popularity of smoothies in recent years, these blenders have become the most-used kitchen appliances in many kitchens. We’ve personally tried several different iterations of the top two contenders: Blendtec and Vitamix and while they are both amazing, I think we will stick with our current favorite for many, many years…

My Top Choice: Vitamix 750 Professional Series

We have this brushed stainless steel Vitamix 750 Professional and I love it! It has a 2.2 horsepower motor and blends quickly and completely.

The biggest (and possibly only) downside to this blender? The price.

Most people won’t want to drop $600+ on a blender and there are some less expensive options (see below) that work almost as well. We opted for this one because it is professional grade and our blender gets a lot of daily use making nut butters, smoothies and even soups.

Our very first Vitamix was a refurbished 5200 that we saved up for months and months to get as newlyweds. It was such an improvement over our $30 wedding gift blender and we used it for many years. The only downside was that it didn’t fit well under the cabinet on the counter and the jar was too big to fit in any of our kitchen cabinets. This meant that with very limited counter space, it was always in the middle of the counter in two pieces and in the way. We used that blender daily for over five years and it was still running like a champ when we passed it on to a family member.

The newer professional series fixes this with a shorter design and is our daily blender now. In fact, we now store ours in a kitchen cabinet so it isn’t on the counter at all!

Vitamix Pros & Cons

Pros:

  • BPA free carafe
  • 2.2 horsepower motor
  • Spill-proof lid
  • New models fit under counter or store in cabinet
  • Four blades for faster blending
  • Choice of many restaurants and bars for its consistent and resilient performance
  • “Self Cleaning”- if you put soapy water in it, it will clean itself and just needs to be rinsed

Cons:

  • Pricy
  • Loud (due to the powerful motor, though this is true with all high-speed blenders)
  • Not dishwasher safe

Blendtec vs. Vitamix

Blendtec Review- Blendtec vs Vitamix

A few years ago, I had the chance to use a Blendtec for a while. Blendtec is another great option with comparable engine speed and performance. At the time, I liked that the Blendtec was shorter and easier to store, though as mentioned, that has been resolved with newer Vitamix models.

Both have good warranties, BPA free carafes, and are a great choice as a home blender. The reason that the new Vitamix still wins in my book is that the lid has a latch system that stays on (we had a couple accidents with the Blendtec) and the Vitamix has a manual control system vs. the computerized Blendtec system. Also, Vitamix has 4 blades to Blendtec’s two.

So Vitmix wins, though Blendtec is a great runner-up.

More Budget Friendly Vitamix

We have the top of the line Professional Series Vitamix but there are other great models that cost about half the price.

Best choice: The Certified Refurbished Vitamix 5300 still fits under the cabinet on a counter, has a long-lasting powerful motor, and is about half the price of the professional series.

Best Budget Friendly Blender

If a restaurant-grade high speed blender isn’t in the budget, there are some lower-priced options that perform almost as well! In fact, looking back, these would have been a great choice instead of the Vitamix when our budget was much tighter several years ago.

Top Choice: Ninja Pro

The Ninja Professional Blender is a great value and a great blender. It has close to the power of a true high speed blender and can do many of the same things at a fraction of the price.

We got to try this one at a rental house while on vacation. I was impressed with the power of the Ninja, and at under $100 it is a much less costly alternative to the two big brands. The Ninja doesn’t quite measure up to the power of the Vitamix but it can accomplish almost all of the same functions and has great reviews.

Easiest Blender for Kids

My older kids easily work most kitchen appliances and can even safely handle a chef’s knife (thanks to the Kids Cook Real Food course), but high speed blenders are not a toy, and I don’t let our younger kids use ours. It’s too easy (even for an adult) to leave a spoon in and blow out the motor or not latch the top and paint the kitchen. (I’m guilty of that one!)

A while back, we got a Magic Bullet as a gift. I almost didn’t take it out of the box because we use our Vitamix for everything, but I wondered if it would be a good option for the kids and decided to try it because it doesn’t take up much room.

I found that the size and speed are great for kids to make individual smoothies as long as they know the proportions and not to overfill. It was also convenient for chopping foods and making things like guacamole.

I wouldn’t consider it comparable to the options above and wouldn’t have purchased it, but it has been a convenient and inexpensive option to let the kids use.

Best Immersion Blender

I could write an ode to my immersion blender because I use it so often. We had a Cuisinart immersion blender for almost a decade and when it eventually died, we replaced it with the Oxa 4-in-1 Immersion Blender and we absolutely love it!

Immersion blenders are fantastic when you don’t need the power (or cleanup) of a high speed blender. I also use this all the time for blending soups and sauces in the pan without having to risk transferring them to a blender. Since the immersion blender is stainless steel, this also minimizes plastic touching hot foods.

As a bonus, the OXA has attachments that whisk and that chop (great for onions without the tears). Personally, I consider both a regular high speed blender and an immersion blender to be necessary kitchen tools since I use them in such different ways.

There are lots of options available when it comes to blenders, but these are my personal favorites and have met the needs of our family.

What is your favorite blender? Do you agree with my blender reviews? Share below!

Sources
Katie Wells Avatar

About Katie Wells

Katie Wells, CTNC, MCHC, Founder of Wellness Mama and Co-founder of Wellnesse, has a background in research, journalism, and nutrition. As a mom of six, she turned to research and took health into her own hands to find answers to her health problems. WellnessMama.com is the culmination of her thousands of hours of research and all posts are medically reviewed and verified by the Wellness Mama research team. Katie is also the author of the bestselling books The Wellness Mama Cookbook and The Wellness Mama 5-Step Lifestyle Detox.

Comments

114 responses to “Blender Reviews: Blendtec vs. Vitamix (& Others)”

  1. Kathy Avatar

    Thanks for all the reviews! I replaced my Kitchen Aid with a Ninja. It worked well for smoothies, grinding ice, and I loved the smaller container for frozen berry ice cream. But it is stalling and freezing up now. I was thinking of biting the bullet and buying one of the big boys (Vitamix or Blendtec). But I always do research before buying another piece of kitchen gear. I have a old Cuisinart food processor and love it. Do they both heat up?

    1. Brandy Avatar

      Both the Blendtec and Vitamix blend at such a high speed they both will heat the food if left to run too long. Neither of them have a heating element though. They both will make great smoothies, ice cream, crushed ice etc. Hope that helps.

  2. Michele Avatar
    Michele

    Interesting! I have been on the fence about either for years because I just don’t want any plastic touching my food and neither make a glass or stainless steel container. We have the base of a 10yo blender that works fine (the new versions do not per reviews) but had to replace the old carafe when I chipped it. That new one leaks. They just don’t make them like they used to!

    That said, I’ve been eyeing them at Costco and they had a special model and the dry container on special last Friday so I picked one up. But I think I’ll be taking it back as the plastic container really bothers me.

    DH uses our glass blender every morning for his butter coffee and I just can’t see putting a hot liquid into plastic, especially an acidic one. Maybe these new containers are BPA free, but what are we going to find soon that is in them instead?

    What I’d love to see is a Vitamix or a Blendtec with a stainless steel container if they won’t do glass again. I’m not really interesting in an older model as I want one appliance that can replace my food processor (which I mostly use these days for butters and grinding) and my blender.

  3. Lisa Wolfe Avatar
    Lisa Wolfe

    I have had a Vitamix for the past 12 years or so and when it was giving out last year I decided to replace it with a Blendtec, since it was a bit less expensive and got pretty good reviews as being on a par with the Vitamix. Not long after I got it, the blade assembly in the container seized up and I had to get the container replaced. They replaced it with no hassle. However, several times when I had a mixture blending on one of their settings, (designed presumably so that one can walk away from it and know it will shut off in a timely manner) the top popped off and i found myself with a mess to clean up. I returned the thing and went back to the Vitamix; got a good deal on one at Costco. The lids just don’t seem to be sturdy enough to stay put reliably when under the pressure of high speed.

  4. Kathi Petersen Avatar
    Kathi Petersen

    I love how everyone mentions that the Vitamix won’t fit under their cupboards on their counter. I built a special marble baking counter under my windows, that has no upper cabinets above it, just for my Vitamix and Kitchenaid!

  5. Tamara Avatar

    I thought your review was unfair and not complete. You were not comparing “apples to apples” in my opinion. Vitamix does have a shorter, wider container that refutes most of what you said in your review. It fits easily under my counter, is easy to scoop out of the container, AND my vitamix professional 750 has a 10 year warranty and is very QUIET. It also has presets. I understand some may not want to spend the $ for a 750, but the wider, shorter container fits on any model vitamix. I know there will always be a rivalry between Blendtec and Vitamix, but your review was for your old model vitamix comparing to a new model Blendtec. Like comparing apples to oranges….

  6. Rebekah Avatar
    Rebekah

    I have a weird infatuation with my Blendtec. Being extremely frugal minded, I felt I had to really be able to justify the $300 purchase at Costco. So after burning up my Ninja trying to make almond butter, I took the leap. I’ve never looked back. I’ve used mine over 2000 times in about a year, and I can’t imagine trying to cook without it. I think that when I bought it is when I first started to really enjoy cooking.

    I also chose Blendtec because of the price compared to vitamix, and it fit under the counter.

  7. Susan R Avatar
    Susan R

    I am glad to see that you ran this review and had to laugh how funny you and so many are about the need to be loyal to your VitaMix. Last Fall I went in search for a blender to replace my well used Kitchen Aid blender. When my husband donated our very old and rarely used Cuisinart Food Processor, I had no idea how much I would miss it, so I went looking for a blender that would do a few food processing tasks as well. I never spend this much money on anything without researching it to death which brought me to the choice of a VitaMix or the Blendtec. I had the opportunity to borrow my friends VitaMix for a day. It was powerful enough but I didn’t like that it didn’t fit under my cabinets and I didn’t like having to use the plunger and found it awkward to clean. When I found the Blendtec along with its smaller sidekick on sale through Costco online I said that is it, my decision was made. I LOVE this blender . . everything about it.

  8. Heidi Green Avatar
    Heidi Green

    I’ve used both blenders and I greatly prefer the Blendtec!! It’s short enough to go under my cupboards, isn’t as bulky, is easier to clean (the vitamix lid is a large, weird shape and the sides of the jar are bumpy as opposed to the flat sides of the BT), the jar fits in my dishwasher, and I love how I don’t have to stand by and use a tamper to get the results I want. I don’t get why people are upset that the Blendtec doesn’t give them perfect results when they push the preset button… it’s just a guideline. Every recipe is going to be different so you’ll need to use the pulse button or run it through the cycle again till you get the right consistency – not a big deal imo. I bought my blender from Costco when they were running a special including both the 4 side and the wild side jars but I’ve seen new bundles recently with a twister jar. I just purchased the twister jar later because I wanted to get into thicker blends (nut butters). Although the bigger jars can blend nut butters, the smaller jar is definitely an easier option (the downside being additional cost). Good luck to all of you looking to purchase one. Although I LOVE and would recommend Blendtec, I think either blender is a gift to a healthy kitchen! 🙂

  9. Tanya Saunders Avatar
    Tanya Saunders

    I love that these expensive blenders make nut butters and such without as much fuss as a regular blender, but the cost, whew! My mom has the vitamix and I have a $60 Oster (glass pitcher and 4 blades) and I could not tell the difference in the smoothies I drink every day. I cannot make soup or nut butters, but I have made different flours as well. So, for people who cannot spring for even the $2-300 refurbished just yet, Oster makes an amazing blender as well.

    1. Katie - Wellness Mama Avatar

      When I first got married we had an Oster blender which I used daily to make smoothies for my husband. It lasted less than a year before the motor stopped working.

      1. G Avatar

        I’ve had my Oster 4-blade blender with glass pitcher for around 10 years and it still works VERY well. I’ve never used a Blentec or Vitamix (although I coveted the Vitamix as a high-school kid when I saw the infomercials of ice cream and hot soup making), but compared to other <$100 blenders I've used, the Oster is tops. I didn't know the Vitamix was no longer available in stainless steel. Seems like a downgrade.

        1. donda Avatar

          We have a newer model and hate the vitamix. We would gladly go back to the one to the stainless steel one. The new one does not have reversing blades and the new one simply does not work for us. We have the dry and wet pitchers…

        2. Cindi Avatar

          I have the stainless steel one I purchased in the early 90’s and it is stainless steel. They came out with the plastic one right after I got mine and I was like why? I remember they touted the stainless steel one as having the 4 wide sides and the stainless steel was the best for temp control when making soup and ice cream. I have loved it except for one thing: it won’t fit under cabinets. So I’ve got a Blendtec coming in and will see how that does. But I’ve even used the Vitamix to grind wheat.

    2. Heather Avatar
      Heather

      I had an Oster one as well. And about a dozen others. I make stuff in the blender all the time and I was ALWAYS swearing at them! We got a blendtec a couple years ago and It is a million times better than all the other crap blenders I have gone through (including TWO magic bullet sets!). It is a huge up front cost but SO worth it!

  10. Karen Avatar

    This is really interesting to read. When I was trying to figure out which one to get for use in culinary school and my nutrition business afterwards, I ended up with the Vitamix because the Blendtec only had about a 9 month warranty and the price was almost the same! I got a 10 year warranty on my Vitamix. However, I have NEVER been happy with the Vitamix. It doesn’t blend like I feel like it should, and I am constantly having to push or scoop the food to the bottom because the canister is so narrow at the bottom, it doesn’t suck it down on its own. Major pain! I would totally have gotten a BlendTec if the warranties were the same when I was looking!

  11. Colleen Avatar
    Colleen

    We recently bought a refurbished vitamix. It has a shorter and wider profile than the one you have pictured but our cupboards are so low that it still doesn’t fit. I am very happy with it. The only thing that concerns me is that it doesn’t lock to the base, so when mixing something that requires the tamper and adjusting speed manually, I am afraid it will come off while running. I did think of getting the BlenDTec but hadn’t seen as many reviews of it. I’m glad to know it compares to the vitamix for future reference.

  12. krisann Avatar
    krisann

    I’ve had my Vitamix for over 10 years and loved it, but it is big and i don’t like cleaning it either. This year i got the Nutribullet (not Magicbullet) and it is now my go to unit. It makes green smoothies fast, the clean up is a breeze, and it’s footprint is small so my counter doesn’t look cluttered. They are carrying these at Costco for the best price, you can also get one at Bed Bath and Beyond with a 20% off coupon.

  13. Angie Avatar

    I bought the Blendtec last summer, and I love it! I had the Vitamix years ago, and it was OK. I own every kind of juicer (and fancy blenders) there is, and they’re fine too, if you have the counter space, and like to spend your time cleaning the accessories.
    This one fits under the counter, I can put the whole fruit/vegetable into it (I do remove stems), and out comes a juice that you can dilute anyway you want. I’ve made flour, butters, batters, etc…
    I don’t cook much anymore (lazy), but that I use! I can throw in stuff that’s looking ‘tired’ (but not moldy or rotten), parsley stems, celery leaves, etc… and out comes fresh nutrition.
    I throw in pills that I’m too lazy to take, leftover herb teas, ginger, turmeric, cinnamon, Vitamin C powder, gelatin, lecithin, Inositol, black seeds, flax, etc…
    Handmade in the USA, and there are NO sharp blades to wear out. Cleans easily, and the special spatulas are perfect. No waste. I bought the smaller jar too.
    The counter says I’ve used it 158 times since last July. That’s pretty good for me. Did I mention I’m lazy? 😀

    1. Lydia Avatar

      Only 158 times? We have used our over 1000 times since we got it a little over a year ago. We LOVE our Blendtec.

    2. Jill Avatar

      So, you use your blendtec as a juicer too? I was considering buying a juicer, but if I can do the same with a blendtec…. that might be the way to go. I love juices with ginger in it… how is the blendtec with making ginger into juice? How is it making small amounts of juice? Thanks!

      1. Heather Avatar
        Heather

        It will make anything with juice into juice, but let me tell you lol. From personal experience, what is actually like 20 oz juiced is like 40 oz in the blender. And pulpy and gross (I am talking about the mean green lol). So if you are juicing and trying to not gag over a bunch of veggies, do yourself a favor and juice them! However, I LOVE my blendtec for everything else 🙂

  14. Brandy Avatar

    I have a Vitamix and bought a Blendtec because I thought I would like it (because of the presets). The next day I returned it because I didn’t like it. It took a long time to make nut butters because it didn’t have a tamper like the Vitamix. Also when I made smoothies with the pre set functions it always left unblended chunks in the top. (I have a family of 6 so we need to be able to blend a lot of smoothie at one time) I recently bought a new Vitamix that has presets like the Blendtec and I love it even more than the original. I can fill and even over fill the Vitamix and it blends everything perfectly every time!

  15. Linda Moelter Avatar
    Linda Moelter

    I also have my vitamix with the stainless steel container and I love it. I have used both its heating and cooling capabilities for making soups or ice cream.

  16. Mike Moser Avatar
    Mike Moser

    Check on e-bay or Craigslist for either blender to save some money. I love my Vitamix but would like a blender easier to clean. Thank you for the comparison.

  17. Jayne Avatar

    I would really like to see you do a review of the Ninja Ultima. I feel it should be classed in the Vitamix/Blendtec category as it has same features and does the same as these others do. New price is $249.00. and worth every penny!

    1. Kriston Tiff Avatar
      Kriston Tiff

      Oh no! Not even fair to compare the poor ninja to Vitamix or Blendtec. Sorry, that ninja doesn’t last with heavy use. Mine didn’t last a full year and what I needed replaced and fixed the warranty didn’t cover. Never have had a single issue with my vitamix- which I purchased for $259, by the way. They are simply not in the same category. I can tell you from experience.

      1. Kathi Petersen Avatar
        Kathi Petersen

        Wow, great deal you got on your vitamix! I’ve used my heavily since I purchased it in 1982 or so, but I spent over $750 for it!!

      2. Brunine Avatar

        I also would not recommend Ninja purely based on bad quality experience. For 1 I barely ever use the blender attachment I use the food processor attachment BUT im not really a fan of the blender part anyways….. The plastic on the bottom of the food processor were the screws are is ll cracked and damaged, if I were to remove the screws the plastic would just crumble and would be useless, as for now it still works but I wish I could clean in there, I can’t though as I would need to remove the screws so I’m afraid there is bacteria in there, for now I just use the sanitize setting on the dishwasher every time i use it. So disappointing, I don’t know how long the warranty lasts but I haven’t contacted them as I’m pretty sure it was only a year and we’ve had it longer than that… We don’t have a lot of money so a vitamix/blendtec is a far off dream, but I’m disappointed that our ninja is already showing signs of poor quality. Will never purchase a Ninja product again… I know this isn’t about the actual blender, but it is about the brand and the quality they have, or rather don’t have…

    2. Wendy Avatar

      I have a vitamix 5200 and a Ninja extreme the Vitamix is a MUCH MUCH MUCH better as the Ninja is not in the same category as the Excellent Vitamix
      The Vitamix 5200 makes a smoothie that is extremely smooth they Ninja on the other hand chops the food into Larger particle size and there for smoothies with the Ninja are Not very smooth

  18. Kathi Petersen Avatar
    Kathi Petersen

    Wow, I’m astonished. I still use the same Vitamix I bought in the early 70s with the stainless steel container. I LOVE my vitamix. I’d recommend getting an old vitamix with a stainless container, they still come up for sale on line. I keep trying to get Vitamix to make a retro version in stainless steel, I think people would love that. I don’t like the new plastic containers …

      1. Kathi Petersen Avatar
        Kathi Petersen

        I looked this week on ebay and there are quite a few on there …

        1. Sierra Avatar

          Kathi, I also have a stainless steel Vitamix from the 70s (it was a hand me down), and I love it although recently it has started leeking out the side where the little black rubber band thing goes around. I don’t know how to fix it and I called and they told me it would cost $89 for a replacement blade set and that’s all they can do. Which means I might as well just try to find another old Vitamix… Have you ever had that issue with yours??

          1. Jillian Avatar

            Hi. We had a SS Vitamix which we bought from a friend moving overseas. It worked great for a few years but then finally started showing its age – leakage, motor issues, etc. We called Vitamix and they offered us a $100 credit towards a refurbished new model, so we ended up getting the 5200 for $225 because of the credit. You may try calling them and ask for that if you don’t mind upgrading to the newer model. Good luck!

        2. Kathi Petersen Avatar
          Kathi Petersen

          Sierra: I had to buy a blade assembly once. Mine never leaked there though, although my black rubber trim piece is long gone …

  19. Vicky Lyashenko Avatar
    Vicky Lyashenko

    Ah this is soo awesome! Thank you so much Katie for sharing this review! I was brainwashed to think Vitamix was better and kept telling my husband I wanted the vitamix, nothing else. I now have a change of heart and will tell my husband, yet again, that he is right. Thank you so much!

    Xo

  20. Eva Avatar

    I’ve been thinking about selling my Vitamix and getting a Blendtec because of the Blendtec’s twister jar–I’ve heard that it makes it much easier to get the food out of the pitcher and I assume that also means less waste. What about making coconut butter, nut/seed butter, or other thick, pasty things? Did you do any of those in the Blendtec and which did you find easier to clean?

      1. Eva Avatar

        Thanks so much for letting me know–that relieves a lot of buyer’s regret I’ve had!

      2. Carla Avatar

        Any idea on if either of those companies will be offering a glass ir stainless steel carafe? Love the blenders, but continue to be uneasy about the plastic carafe–especially when using hot liquids.

        1. Lindsay Avatar

          I own a vitamix and have made soap in it using real lye. Trust me, the plastic is not affected by heat or even caustic chemicals. It’s tough! 🙂

          1. Karen Avatar

            I read soup instead of soap and thought man I’m not eating at her house lol. But good to know about the heat thing, specifically I want to make soups with mine.

    1. Kimberly Avatar

      Just another side to things. I have a Vitamix….my friend a Blendtex. We got them about the same time. She had a problem with a rubber gasket that began to degrade and took it back. She got another Blendtex and in about a year the same thing happened. She then got a Vitamix. I have had my Vitamix for about 3 years and could not be happier. I have never had a Blendtex but would not consider knowing what problems my friend had with hers. But I do love your site. Thanks for all.

      1. Gwen B Avatar

        I used a Blendtec for a year and a half and I never had any issues with it at all. Just my two cents. I think you get lemons in any electrical appliance sometimes, including cars.

    2. adrienne Avatar

      I purchased a Vitamix knockoff…the healthMaster Elite. When I say knock off, it has near identical, possibly interchangeable parts. It is slightly higher in specs than a Vitamix and a lifetime warranty. It is the the go to machine in my house. I’ve tried other blenders and with the exception of an actual Vitamix, nothing comes close to performance. it’s a great option if you’re absolutely looking for something under $200. I got mine on Amazon. To resolve the storage height issue I flip the lid upside down and it fits…just barely. The plunger goes in the utensil drawer.

    3. trevin Avatar
      trevin

      Blendtec sucks when your warranty is up and you need replacement inside parts they will not give sell them to yo you need to ship back for them to repairu that’s a bunch of bull they don’t back their product with replacement motor parts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *